Recently, I have become quite curious to understand the Universe and theories explaining it’s origin, age, character, shape, etc. So, I finally posted the following post at sci.astro.amateur. Here’s the copy-paste of the same with minor formatting. If you have thoughts/advice, please do comment.
I am neither an astronomer nor a physicist. But I’ve become curious to learn about the origin of the Universe and have been trying to understand the Big Bang.
After going through the theory of Big Bang (not in the level of depth that most educated physicists or astronomers would study), I have developed some questions on the Big Bang. When I noticed this sci.astro.amateur group, I felt perhaps, I could ask them here. (Please forgive me and let me know if I have posted to the wrong group or if my questions appear silly/too basic to you)
I would appreciate any guidance / pointers to references that would help me with answers:
1 (a) “According to the Big Bang model, the universe expanded from an extremely dense and hot state and continues to expand today. A common
analogy explains that space itself is expanding, carrying galaxies with it, like raisins in a rising loaf of bread.” – Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bang
1 (b) On the same Wikipedia page, there is also a reference to “primeval atom”, which appears to be the accepted theory from which the Universe emerged. (Please correct me)
QUESTIONS:
- Where did the primeval atom come from?
- What was the composition of the atom? Makes me think, how tremendously intelligent and complex the composition of this primeval atom would be that upon the Big Bang, it led to the systematic emergence of numerous galaxies, elements, compounds, and even life!
- What intelligence created this atom or how did it come into existence?
- If the overall energy in the Universe is constant, why at a finite point in potentially infinite past did the primeval atom containing constant energy burst with a Big Bang?
2. Is redhift of light to longer wavelengths the only base for accepting that the galaxies are moving away from each other?
3. If, indeed, the galaxies were moving from each other can there be no other possibility, other than that the Universe is expanding? Is there any other scientific base with sufficient proof to the theory of the expansion of Universe?
Thanks in advance for helping me.
Regards,
Chintan Zaveri.
Did you enjoy this post? Why not leave a comment below and continue the conversation, or subscribe to my feed and get articles like this delivered automatically to your feed reader.
I am very happy that there are people like you who are more inquisitive about the universe.
If god wants he will give the clue.but not certainly to them whom he has created for some specific work like us
I will put up my thinking as follow
1)Man is a very very tiny part of whole universe( even our earth is like a small atom in this whole universe
2)all the organs are including eyes & brain are given to man all mighty who has also created the universe
3)what we see, learn and conclude from whatever knowledge we absorbed so far by our limited power of the brain.(Brain is going to cremated with our body when we will die)
4)we are not born in this world with our wish nor we will die with our wish.
5)what we learn ,what we do, what we should not do has been already programmed by the all mighty
6)what I am trying to convince you that we shall be wasting our valuable time in knowing the big bang theory or about the atom and will create lot of confusion and wrong concepts as whole life it self is like dream to every body.
7)in span of time I will not be there nor you will be there. I am not scientist nor you are a scientist
all scientist will go on forming there theories on trial & error basis because god never keeps any clue of his ultimate knowledge
9) All man made inventions of the world are actually gifts of the god to the man kind as god wants evaluate the man kind to protect his own creations & other creatures in the world .
10) If you really wants to about the universal powers & secrets you to lot of penance as you know
in Hindu mythology god like Bhagvan Vishnu Bhavan Shiva also do lot of meditations .without meditations & inner urge nothing is achieved nor gained.
11) you should have a spiritual Guru who will in real sense help you out
I wish you best of luck